Articles

Truckling to Muslims trumps Health and Safety

By July 13, 2013February 18th, 2021No Comments
 
Teachers ‘denied schoolboy, 10, water on the hottest day of the year to avoid upsetting Muslim pupils during Ramadan’
 
  • Kora Blagden claims her son was told he could not drink water
  • She says teacher told him it could be unfair to fasting classmates
  • Said teacher made decision on Thursday when temperatures hit 28 degrees

By Daily Mail Reporter

12 July 2013

Kora Blagden, 32, claimed a teacher at her son Luke’s school refused to let the 10-year old drink from his water bottle because it was ‘unfair’ to fasting classmates.

Many pupils at Charles Dickens Primary School, Portsmouth, Hampshire, are fasting during Ramadan, which means they refrain from taking food or water between sunrise and sunset for around 30 days, depending on the moon.

  
Kora Blagden has complained to her school as she says her son Luke was told he could not drink water in case it upset pupils who were fasting
Luke Blagden (left), 10, left and Alfie Blagden, 8, the children of Kora Blagden
 

Kora Blagden (top) has complained to the school as she says her son Luke (above, stood on the left) was told he could not drink water in case it upset pupils who were fasting

Mother-of-four Kora said: ‘Just before bedtime me and my sons Luke, ten, and Alfie, eight, were talking about Ramadan as we had seen it on the news.

‘Luke said to me he was told he wasn’t allowed to drink in class by his teacher.

‘The reason being, a child who is fasting had a headache and the teacher said it would be unfair if the other children drank in front of the pupil.

Ban packed lunches so children eat healthy [halal] school dinners, headteachers urged in drive for free meals for under-11s

 ‘They normally have their bottles on their table but they were kept in a tray by the teacher.

‘He went along with it but he was thirsty and didn’t want to offend the other children.

‘Alfie said he was allowed to drink in the morning but not in the afternoon.

 A number of pupils at Charles Dickens Primary School, Portsmouth, Hampshire, are fasting during Ramadan A number of pupils at Charles Dickens Primary School, Portsmouth, Hampshire, are fasting during Ramadan
 

‘Luke was dehydrated when he got home and drank three glasses of water straight away.’

The teacher made the ruling on Thursday when temperatures soared to 28C.

Ms Blagden confronted deputy head Lisa Florence before lessons began today and was given a verbal apology for the incident.

‘The deputy head said it was not what they had been told to do and it is only what children of Muslim faith do’ – Kora Blagden.

She said: ‘I spoke to the deputy head and told them what Luke had said to me and I asked why this was allowed.

‘She said it wasn’t fair my son was refused a drink in lesson and therefore drank nothing in lesson time all day.

‘She said they will be speaking with Luke and the teacher, and stated she was sorry my children felt [!] they could not drink.

‘The deputy head said it was not what they had been told to do and it is only what children of Muslim faith do.

‘I have no problem with that but I don’t wish my sons to be told they can’t drink water.

‘Personally I think it is very wrong.’

Charles Dickens is an inner-city school just streets away from the birthplace of the world-famous author of the same name.

The school said there was no ban on children from other religions having food and drink during Ramadan [there should be no school-imposed ‘ban’ for any children] but refused to comment on this individual case.

Portsmouth City Council, which runs the 300-pupil school, also declined to comment.

Daily Mail